Hell, this is supposed to be a reviews page? Blimey!
Anyway, I finally came around seeing this tonight, and it was a highlight. I hadn't really done any research but kinda expected a sort of Narnian "let's jump into the wardrobe and enter a fantasy world" approach. However, it was WAY different and WAY better than that. I yet have to settle my thoughts, because the amount of information gained from the Making-Of and from the interviews with the novel's author and the rest of the extra stuff on the DVD was almost too much to absorb at once.
First, I wasn't aware of this being such a popular and famous children's story. This adds a very special edge to it in the first place, for novel adaptations follow certain rules and require very intense spadework.
The strongest themes for me are obviously friendship and the power of imagination. Having been a
very imaginative child myself who spent most of his time buried in books and exploring fantasy worlds, and having written fantasy stories myself, I was absolutely mesmerized by the way this story cherished, transformed and portrayed the imaginative mind of these two kids. Now add this to the genuine portrayal of two outcasts who live in different but similarly lonely enviroments both at home and at school, and the power of imagination and the positive energy exuding from this friendship becomes inspiring and anything but perfunctory. The two young actors (btw. Anna-Sophia is probably the most handsome and lovely young actress I've ever seen) interact with incredible dignity and skill. Their friendship is the main anchor of the story, and the tragedy that ensues makes the entire experience even more valuable and instructive. It thus becomes a perfect medley of fantasy, tragedy and genuine issues of growing up, being and accepting yourself and living your dreams.
I am tempted to give it 10 stars indeed.